fall2006math530csula

 

Question about limit points

Page history last edited by mkrebs@... 3 yrs ago

Question On page 111, Number 2, we are asked, "If f:X to Y is continuous, if x is a limit point of a subset A of X is it necessarily true that f(x) is a limit point of f(A) ?"

 

I'm confused about the notation... isn't

f(x) an element of f(A)? f(A is a set, right? So even if f were a contant function so everything goes to 7, wouldn't f(x)=7 and f(A)= {7} I'm not sure if I should say it's the same or not.

 

 

Answer Yes, f(x) is an element of f(A). But that doesn't mean that f(x) is a limit point of f(A).

 

As for notation, f(A) = {f(x):x is in A}.

 

In fact, you've given an example where this fails. To be more precise: Let R be the set of real numbers, in the usual topology. Let f be the function from R to R such that f(x)=7 for all x in R.

 

Let A=R. Then 52 is a limit point of A, since every open set of R containing 52 also contains a point of A other than 52.

 

Now f(A)={7} and f(52)=7. So f(52) is not a limit point of f(A). The open interval (6,8), for example, is an open set containing f(52), but it does not contain any point of f(A) other than f(52).

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.